Forgot your password?
active network: Visordown : Golfmagic : Outdoorsmagic  
already a member?
Welcome to Visordown
  •  
  • Home
  • News
  • Blog
  • Bike Reviews
  • Kit Reviews
  • Forums
  • Features
  • Directory
  • Classifieds
  • Win
About Visordown | Join Visordown | Write for Visordown | Contact Us | Sitemap | RSS
General news | New bikes | Industry | Bizarre | General Racing news | Moto GP | WSB | BSB
Snippets | Product News | Long Termers | Editor's Blog
Custom | Supermoto | Sportsbikes | Naked | Tourers | Off Road | Classics | Sports Tourers | Scooters | Adventure
Helmets | Leather jackets | 1pc suits | Boots | Gloves | Cleaning kit | Chain lube | Locks & chains | Tyres
General | Jokes | Gallery | Touring | Supermoto | Trackdays | Workshop | Classic Bikes
First Rides | Used Tests | Track Guides | Advanced Riding | Top 10s | Interviews | General Features | How to do anything
Insurance | Shopping | Trackday Calendar | Classifieds
Sell Your Bike | Browse all bikes | BMW | Ducati | Honda | Kawasaki | Suzuki | Triumph | Yamaha
Win
Road Tests
You are looking at: Home : Road Tests

Road Test: BMW R1150GS V R1200GS

The bold, brash and huge 1200 GS Adventure takes on its dad - the tough, slugging film star 1150 GS Adventure in the wilds of Wales.

Tweet
Posted: 26 January 2011
by Bertie Simmonds





BMW made R1150GS Adventures for some three years before Ewbie and Charlie Bikeman blagged a couple, no, sorry, three, bikes for their Long Way Round odyssey. That said, their hugely publicised trek bestowed added superstar status to an already high-profile machine.

Sales of the biggest dirt bike known to mankind went stellar. The R1150GS Adventure became, and remains, an icon. But now it's being consigned to the annuls of history. The R1200GS Adventure, launched last year, has redefined BMW's huge-overlander bike concept. Faster, lighter and certainly flashier (in the most macho manner possible) it's also quite a lot lighter than the outgoing model.

The question is, is it actually better?

ENGINE

Okay this is easy; the 1200 motor aces the 1150's, quite considerably. The spec charts tell it pretty much like it is. And on the dyno the 1200 makes a good 20bhp more than the 1150 and there's around 12 percent more torque too. And as all this extra grunt is propelling a substantially lighter bike it really is a non-contest. Or is it?

Jump on the 1150 and you'll be immediately impressed. Our example, now some five years old (and owned by snapper Oli) has a hefty 41,000 miles on the clock, yet the motor feels as good as new. Tweak the throttle and it bounds energetically up the road. The motor feels solid, dependable with just enough shuddering surge to be interesting. Its forte is low to mid, simply short shift at about 4000rpm and let the torque punt you along.

The 1200 feels immediately different. Despite giving nothing away to the 1150 in low down pull, the 1200's character is typified by a feeling of being quicker revving with most of the thrust coming through the mid range. To quote Oli, it feels, 'airy'. But he's a photographer and should not be trusted with words. We think he means it's a light flywheel feel, free spinning - rev happy (for a BMW flat twin, that is).

We put the two head-to-head for some top gear roll-ons and the 1200 simply tears away, even from as slow as 40mph, which shows that even while the 1150 feels to have impressive bottom end, the 1200 has more.
However, if you are off-road oriented then the character of the 1150's motor will still feel the better of the two. It's fair to say when you're hitting the dirt with these monsters you will, by necessity, be doing it in a slower, more considered manner - these are not motocrossers and neither have the suspension to tackle gnarly stuff at speed. And so the 1150's better suited to this pace with its wonderfully rich low to mid range grunt. Again the 1200 will probably surge past like a raped ape but that won't stop the 1150 rider from feeling at peace with his bike and the world.

On the road though, you ultimately have to tip the nod to the 1200. It's in the overtakes you notice it most, with the 1200 you twist the throttle and you're past. On the 1150, you plan ahead, you time the move and then peg down a gear and finally give it the herbs. Okay, it's better than that, but by comparison, it is more work. On the motorway the 1150 feels best at around 85mph, the 1200 at 90mph.

Of course if you exercise a modicum of restraint you'd find these air-cooled flat twins are far more fuel efficient when you drop back to a cruising speed of 56mph (ish) - then they'll go a good 400 miles on their huge tanks, both types. Not that's you'd ever cruise at 56mph.

We should mention the transmissions too. Both feature six speed 'boxes matched to massive dry single-plate clutch units. Surprisingly they feel identical, despite the age of the 1150 and the brand-newness of the 1200. Both shift well for their type, being reasonably positive and accurate when shifted under load. And both make the peculiar dropped-spanner clank when shifting gear mid town centre when there's no load. Both could probably stand to have a longer top gear too.

Should you slip the clutch on either, for a wheelie or to initiate a slide in the dirt, then both will emit a stench akin to a British Rail shunting yard - it must be something in the friction plate material.

Quite simply, we're talking reliability and robustness here. Odd thing is the 1200 is said to have a new gearbox and of course that's a much revised Paralever system - yet is there a quantifiable improvement? Maybe the message is once a BMW always a BMW.

Oh, except for the case of electrical and electronic components. We're talking CAN bus, the onboard digital network come wiring loom fitted to the 1200. This is technology so advanced (apparently) that few understand and certainly no one without BMW's own software and a laptop can repair in the event of a malfunction. For those riders who like to ride to the back and beyond, outside the protective apron of the BMW dealer network, then this is bad news. Overlanders like nothing better than to field fix their bikes using little more than a multi-tool and some baler twine. An inert GS with a flashing digital message 'refer to service manager' is an Outer Mongolian nightmare. So the 1150 is the pick for outback man.

Continue the BMW R1150GS Versus R1200GS Test - 2/2

2005 BMW R1150GS Adventure Specifications

TYPE - TRAIL
PRICE - £5000 (USED)
ENGINE CAPACITY - 1130cc
POWER - 74.8bhp@6800rpm
TORQUE - 66.6lb.ft@5300rpm   
WEIGHT - 253kg
SEAT HEIGHT - 900mm   
FUEL CAPACITY - 30L   
TOP SPEED - 121mph



Previous article
Road Test: 2007 Z750 v FZ6 v GSR v Hornet
Next page
BMW GS Face-off - Page 2


MPG, price, review, for sale, parts, forum, specs, top speed, tyres, specifications, bhp, bmw, r1150gs, r1200gs, adventure, horsepower, pictures, seat height, oil, uk, exhaust
TwitterStumbleUponFacebookDiggRedditGoogle

Related Content

BMW issue worldwide R1200GS safety warning

First ride: 2008 BMW R1200GS Adventure

First Ride: 2007 BMW K1200R Sport

Road Test: BMW K1200R

Looking For Travis: KTM 990, Transalp, BMW HP2

Related Products

BMW R1150GS Adventure (2001 - 2005)

BMW R1150 GS (1999 - 2004)

BMW R1200GS Adventure (2006 - present)

BMW R1200GS (2004 - present)

BMW R1100GS (1994 - 1999)


Discuss this story


frank myer
I have the 1150 model and also used a 1200 for a while.  As you say, the 1200 performs better on road but I prefer the 1150 for remote travel. I'm a guy who likes to  have some  control over any mechanicle repairs that might show up out in the back blocks. With the 1200 and its Canbus computer controlled wiring system,you have Buckleys chance of fixing it when it fails anywhere outside a major Western city. When you get out in the back and beyond  it's one thing you don't want to be worrying about. At the end of the day both models need a couple of hefty guys,or a crane to lift them upright when a fully loaded one gets bogged, or goes down.  In sand, they are an absolute nightmare,and thats when the clutches realy start to cook.Long distance travel with the occational gravel road they are unsurpassed.

Posted: 29/01/2011 at 01:44


billy napier
give me my k100rs any day, ye cant beat a flying suitcase

Posted: 19/11/2011 at 22:07


Michael Sobek
I love my 02 1150SA it is bullet proof,
mine has done over 100,000 klm with 'NO Problems'
in and across all types of road/track/path.
However with the 1200's I do wonder if anyone has actually had
problems with their Canbus system?

Posted: 31/01/2012 at 23:20

Talkback: Road Test: BMW R1150GS V R1200GS

First Name:
Last Name:
Nickname:
Email:
Security Image:
Enter the code shown:

I agree to the site's Terms and Conditions & Code of Conduct:

Most popular

  • Read
  • Discussed
  • Latest
  1. 1
    2012 Honda CBR600RR revealed
  2. 2
    Crash
  3. 3
    Submit your news to Visordown
  4. 4
    2012 BMW S1000RR – more than meets the eye
  5. 5
    “103” engine standard on 2012 Harley big twins
  1. 1
    18 of us are killed or seriously injured each day
  2. 2
    The cars to look out for
  3. 3
    UK motorcycle road safety improves 32% since 1998
  4. 4
    Fake motorcycle police. Why?
  5. 5
    Caption That: Busa samurai
  1. 1
    Splitlath announce 2012 BSB line-up
  2. 2
    Video: MV Agusta F3 begins production
  3. 3
    Moto Guzzi California 1400 revealed
  4. 4
    Aprilia Caponord 1200 leaks
  5. 5
    Hayden undergoing shoulder surgery

Reviews

Husqvarna SMR630
Husqvarna SMR630
in Supermoto
Honda CBR250R
Honda CBR250R
in Sports Tourers
BMW G650GS
BMW G650GS
in Adventure
Suzuki V-Strom 650A (2012 - )
Suzuki V-Strom 650A (2012 - )
in Adventure
Honda Honda CBR600F (2011 - )
Honda Honda CBR600F (2011 - )
in Sports Tourers

Latest Discussion

Mikuni Carb
by ozzi
1 reply
are you ready for your motorcycle change a new fairing?
sale motorcycle fairings
by fairingsworlds
1 reply
Talkback: Frank Thomas Raptor Evo Trouser
very comfortable, lots of pockets, not a bad price either...the armour in mine doesnt quite seat around the knee's brilliantly, and after 6 ...
by Pringle
1 reply
Talkback: RST Razor
not a bad pair of jeans, cool in the summer, warm in winterone minor bug bare is that the stitching on the inside of the pocket is rubbish a...
by Pringle
1 reply
Talkback: Moto Guzzi California 1400 revealed
Loving the look, pity its spoiled by those awful rocker covers.
by Sam Brown 2
1 reply
Facebook

Become a fan of Visordown

Twitter

Follow us on twitter

Subscribe to Bugsplat Newsletter

Click here

Parenting

  • Junior
  • Practical Parenting
  • ThinkBaby
  • MadeForMums

Other Immediate Media Sites

  • RadioTimes
  • Gardeners' World
  • GOLFmagic
  • OUTDOORSmagic
  • Visordown

Our eCommerce Platform

About Visordown

  • Join Visordown
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & conditions
  • Support
  • Advertise with us

Your Visordown

  • RSS

Reviews

  • Custom reviews
  • Sportsbikes reviews
  • Tourers reviews
  • Classics reviews
  • Supermoto reviews
  • Naked reviews
  • Off Road reviews
  • Sports Tourers reviews
  • Scooters reviews
  • Adventure reviews

Insurance

Directory

Competitions

Features

  • Bikes
  • Columns
  • Riding Tips
  • Workshop
  • Reader Articles
  • Off the Wall
  • Video Wall

News

  • Racing news
  • Product news

Home

  • Trackday calendar
  • Gallery
  • Your Crash Gallery
  • 10 Sexiest Bikes
  • Bridgestone Bikers Club

Forums

  • Main forums
  • Supermoto forums
  • Racing forums
  • Bike Shop forums
  • Miscellaneous forums
  • Site issues forums
  • Classifieds forums
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms + conditions
  • Advertise with us

© Immediate Media Company Ltd 2011. This website is owned and published by Immediate Media Company Limited. www.immediatemedia.co.uk