Fork in the road: Harley Street Rod vs. Yamaha R1 - Page 2 of 2

One man's floor is another man's ceiling. The words'sports bike' can mean very different things, so we compare two contrasting takes takes on a common theme.

Posted: 17 January 2011
by Jon Urry

It's a lot more fun than expected too, as it doesn't get overly excited when you turn up the wick - it just needs a little more physical effort. Corner entry preparation is necessary as the Street Rod doesn't have the geometry to start making sudden alterations mid-turn, but the weight keeps it steady and you can punch hard out of bends in the middle three gears, with a steady supply of horsepower up to 8000rpm, and a peak of 116bhp at 8200rpm. Thankfully, to match the relentless surge, it has plenty of braking ability courtesy of Brembo. And with three 300mm discs, the rear contributes significantly to proceedings. Four fingers are required on the lever but feel and feedback is pretty good, and an hour of hard charging failed to produce a hint of fade from the four-piston calipers.

After a few hours on the Street Rod, hopping aboard the R1 was a revelation. The extreme riding
position seems exaggerated after being upright for so long. Your body assumes a racing crouch with your backside at the same level as your hands (the seat is 7cm higher than the Harley's) and you mould into the sculptured bodywork of what is a truly beautiful machine. Of course it's purposeful and minimalist, but the sheer lack of bulk makes the Yamaha seem tiny and slightly intimidating by comparison.

Press the starter button and you instantly know what you're in for. The 20-valve motor is 130cc down on the Harley's, but has double the cylinders and produces an extra 40-plus bhp and at 4000rpm higher. It's about as hardcore as they come.

I rode nothing but sports bikes for 10 years but it still takes a few miles to adjust. Surging forward in first gear is enough to get the adrenalin levels up, and this is where they'll stay. Working through the gearbox at 7000rpm into sixth provides rapid forward motion, and it hasn't even started to get going. Three figure speeds are reached in seconds (like the Harley) but you always feel like you're flying whereas the Street Rod disguises its performance.

Even for a 1000cc Japanese bike everything seems to happen high up in the rev range. Break through the 7000rpm barrier and there's another 5000rpm of sheer power as the world becomes a blur. It's addictive and exhilarating, which is why I'm constantly glancing at the mirrors. The handling is razor sharp and the suspension a little firm, but it can easily handle anything I throw at it. Being 30cm shorter than the Street Rod, it's considerably more agile and quick steering, but far less relaxing too. I think I'm getting a little old for this.

While these two machines couldn't be more different to ride, in some respects they have more in common than you might imagine. Both are good fun, both look cool and both turn heads wherever they go. Running costs will be similar as they share the same insurance groups, return 40mpg and have
similar service intervals. The Harley costs a couple of grand more but will have a stronger residual value as it doesn't compete in a high-tech war.

You could cruise comfortably at high speed on the Harley for a whole day; you could cruise much faster on the Yam, but where and for how long? The R1 comes alive on the racetrack, its natural habitat. The Street Rod will gladly give it a go but is obviously more at home on the road. They both like being revved but the Yamaha begs for more, and indeed requires more to get the best out of it. And, if it's of any importance, the Street Rod will be the winner with the ladies. Hands down.

And in answer to the all-important question: yes, the Street Rod is a realistic alternative to the hyper sports bike. But whether or not this is the future remains to be seen.

Yamaha R1 Specs

SPECS - YAMAHA
TYPE - SUPERSPORTS
PRODUCTION DATE - 2007
PRICE NEW - £8799
ENGINE CAPACITY - 998cc
POWER - 158bhp@12,300rpm
TORQUE - 76lb.ft@9700rpm   
WEIGHT - 172kg
SEAT HEIGHT - 835mm   
FUEL CAPACITY - 18L   
TOP SPEED - 186mph   
0-60     - n/a
TANK RANGE - N/A



Previous page
Fork in the road: Harley Street Rod vs. Yamaha R1
Next article
Road Test: Suzuki Bandit 1200, BMW R1200GS Adventure, Triumph Sprint ST, Yamaha FZ1 Fazer


 
TwitterStumbleUponFacebookDiggRedditGoogle


Discuss this story


bim
harley stopped making the streetrod a couple of years back !

Posted: 17/01/2011 at 19:03


R B
I thought v-rod motors were V4's ?

Posted: 17/01/2011 at 20:08


bim
no, v twins 1130 cc or 1250 for the later models

Posted: 18/01/2011 at 18:34

OK, so let's expand this a bit.

If you couldn't have a sports bike because you've been banned and are paranoid, or are getting old and your knees are knackered, or for whatever other reason listed in the article above, then which way would you go ?

Harley / other cruiser ?

Supermoto or trailie ( big trailie such as Transalp, Africa Twin, F800GS or 690 or bigger KTM, or small light trailie ) ?

Street - street triple or maybe something different such as a TDM ?

Tourer ?

I'm deliberately excliding the 1 litre super-nakeds, as that seems a bit too obvious an alternative, although I guess would be first choice alternative for many.

Just curious.


Posted: 20/01/2011 at 10:37

Harley? V4, you're having a laugh

Posted: 23/01/2011 at 19:57

This was a serious problem for me... I was trying to get out of my faithful Triumph Daytona 1200 and get something that made me wanna speed a bit less... I looked at EVERYTHING for many years and test rode tons of bikes and for years I didnt pull the trigger cause none gave me the thrill of the big Triumph... some came close... BMWs newer bikes are all nice... but here in Japan WAY too expensive... Moto Guzzis are also over priced here... and where would I get it serviced... KTM Super Duke and Adventure were strong contenders... but I couldnt find a used one and couldnt afford new... then along came an unridden used Streetrod... I have ridden an occasional harley before and always hated em... but the Streetrod seemed different... so finally I pulled the trigger... and to be honest... I regret it... its useless for carrying luggage... hell it doesnt even have a helmet lock... and its terrible in bad weather... rain is common here... and my girlfriend hates the back seat and always longs for the return of my Triumph... and its such a porker in everyway compared to the daytona... and though it theory it should require less maitenance but the tires are so damned expensive that buying a set requires serious financial forthought... and it has had more mechanical failures in my 2 years of riding it than my Triumph did in 10... and the dream of customizing it to be a bit more sporty feel fairly flat when I realized all the aftermarket support was to make it look like a heavy shiny paperweight and not a mean street fighter... anyway... its not a bad bike... and probably harleys best... but I miss my Triumph...

Posted: 02/07/2011 at 12:36

Talkback: Fork in the road: Harley Street Rod vs. Yamaha R1