fluke and mikeprytherch - I agree with you both 100%
Smith is an unproven racer. I remember all the fuss Abraham caused when he moved to GP without a single race win in Moto2, and everyone cried 'It's because his Daddy has money! It's unfair to other racers!' - well, what has Smith proved that Abraham didn't? In my opinion he has talent, but he doesn't have that 'racer' mentality and competitive streak that Redding has in spades. I'd like to see Redding on the Tech3 (or anything other than a Ducati) to get out of Moto2 in which his frame does him no favours, and Smith on a competitive bike, such as a Suter or Kalex in Moto2.
As for Cal, although I love seeing a Brit on the world stage, I have always been a bit cautious of backing him. More often than not, when he has put his money where his mouth is, it hasn't paid off.
Dovi is doing well due to a lack of competition, Stoner seems to have his mind elsewhere, Spies has gone off the boil, then you have Rossi and Hayden who are banging their heads against a brick wall.
Next year will be tougher, Stoner will be gone, but Lorenzo is still the man to beat, Rossi will be back on a competitive bike, Bradl will have a year of GP racing under his belt and will be keen to prove himself, it’s make or break for Pedrosa, plus Marquez could be a cat amongst the pigeons.
I really feel the odds are stacked against Dovi, Cal and Smith...