Forgot your password?
active network: Visordown : Golfmagic : Outdoorsmagic  
already a member?
Welcome to Visordown
  •  
  • Home
  • News
  • Blog
  • Bike Reviews
  • Kit Reviews
  • Forums
  • Features
  • Shopping
  • Classifieds
  • Win
About Visordown | Join Visordown | Write for Visordown | Contact Us | Sitemap | RSS
General news | New bikes | Industry | Bizarre | General Racing news | Moto GP | WSB | BSB
Snippets | Product News | Long Termers | Editor's Blog
Custom | Supermoto | Sportsbikes | Naked | Tourers | Off Road | Classics | Sports Tourers | Scooters | Adventure
Helmets | Leather jackets | 1pc suits | Boots | Gloves | Cleaning kit | Chain lube | Locks & chains | Tyres
General | Jokes | Gallery | Touring | Supermoto | Trackdays | Workshop | Classic Bikes
First Rides | Used Tests | Track Guides | Advanced Riding | Top 10s | Interviews | General Features | How to do anything
Sell Your Bike | Browse all bikes | BMW | Ducati | Honda | Kawasaki | Suzuki | Triumph | Yamaha
Win
Column: Michael Scott
You are looking at: Home : Column: Michael Scott

Michael Scott Column - Feb 2009

Mike Scott looks forward to a new MotoGP season, but will the new one-make tyre rule actually make any difference?

Tweet
Posted: 15 February 2009
by Michael Scott

One season ends, the next begins one day later. Yesterday’s race results aren’t even fish’n’chips wrapping, in these days of the download.

The difference this time was the introduction of one-make control tyres. Supposed to even it all up a bit. So what happened, in the final test at Jerez? Rossi was fastest, Pedrosa a fraction slower. In other words, not much changed at all.

Few in racing believe that control tyres will make the racing much closer. Racing’s not like that. The fastest riders always go fastest, no matter what regulations you throw at them.

Dorna, however, seems hell bent on a path of increasingly restrictive rule changes, all introduced with unseemly haste. Who can doubt there will be more? A curb electronics next? Then maybe fixed engine design. All following F1.

But until they pass a rule tying all the motorbikes together, nothing much will change. Dorna has its own business interests at heart. It must make the most of the show.

Pit Bull doesn’t believe that limiting the technology is the way to go about it. Especially when it merely slows everybody down by an equal amount.

Here’s a couple of ideas. Weight penalties. Qualify on pole, you get an extra five kg. Win two races in a row, another five. And so on. That way, you set a challenge for the designers, engineers and riders to overcome.

Better still, use the technology that the most modern test circuits already have – irrigation systems, for wet testing. We all know that wet races are the most exciting and unpredictable. Climate control allows rain to be introduced at the ringmaster’s discretion, just in case any dry race threatens to get too dull.

In the end, we will have to rely on riding talent. MotoGP is especially blessed at the moment, with Rossi and Stoner, Lorenzo and Dovizioso, and a couple more. Racers not rules make for good racing.

In 2008, because Rossi and Lorenzo were using different tyres (Bridgestone and Michelin respectively), protocol and secrecy required a physical barrier down the middle of the pit. This was quite a novelty.

The idea caught on. By the last races the factory Honda team had a similar divide, between Pedrosa (now on Bridgies) and Hayden.

In 2009, with the new mono-tyre rule, this will no longer apply. But at Yamaha, the barrier will remain. They discovered it was actually a better way to work.

This brings to an end years of mealie-mouthed nonsense about team-mates being friendly rivals, working together for the greater good.

More usually, they hate each other. And quite often they let it show.

Rossi has always favoured a one-rider team, though he was happy enough sharing the factory Yamaha pit with Colin Edwards. He knew the Tornado wouldn’t ever be a threat. But he made no secret of his disapproval when Lorenzo was recruited. And he was right: Gorgeous Jorge gave him on-track trouble right from the off.

Even Nicky ‘Mr Nice’ Hayden admits you have to have a bit of hatred for the other riders. “Even when I’m racing with my brothers, I have to find something to hate,” he told me.

Better box them off from one another, like greyhounds, giving them only the odd scent of their rivals. That way, they’re already primed when they’re out on track.

Chummy team-mates, Part Two: There’ll be ice in the Tech 3 pit, after James Toseland stole teammate Edwards’s favourite crew chief away from under his nose at the end of the season.

JT spent his first year working with team stalwart Guy Coulon, a very French paddock eccentric who has been around forever, his wild curly blond mane receding over the decades. He’s an engineer and, long ago, endurance racing hero, but our Sheffield lad found neither every really knew what the other was talking about. (This is not a unique experience, when dealing with the very French.) So behind the scenes he engineered a swap for next year. Much to Edwards’s dismay, when he found out about it.

JT is strikingly polite and mild-mannered, giving a very false impression. If you look at his ruthless streak on the track (he even had the cheek to re-pass Rossi more than once in Australia), you get a clearer measure of the man. He’s a tough competitor, and bears watching for next year.

Sete Gibernau is back, along with many memories of how he earned a reputation as a paddock poser when he was last racing. Sleeves torn off all his T-shirts, designer shades, tragic hair-styles and so on.

So it was unfortunate, when his team was launched in Spain, that the English-language information pack had been translated directly. In Spanish, if you talk about ‘the queen class’ of racing, it quite clearly means MotoGP. Put it in English, however, and it means something quite different. Making Sete Gibernau queen of the grid even before he’d even climbed off the bike to flounce back to his pit.



Previous article
Michael Scott Column - Jan 2009
Next article
Niall Mackenzie Column - Jan 09


mike scott, motogp, one-make tyre rule, bridgestone
TwitterStumbleUponFacebookDiggRedditGoogle

Related Content

MotoGP: One-make tyre rule imminent

New front tyre for MotoGP

Michael Scott Column - Apr 2009

MotoGP: Fuel consumption concerns for Motegi

Bridgestone promise full range for Valencia test

Related Products

Bridgestone Battlax BT-010

Bridgestone Trail Wing

Bridgestone Battlax BT-014

Bridgestone Battlax TH01

Bridgestone Battlax BT-003


Discuss this story

Talkback: Michael Scott Column - Feb 2009

First Name:
Last Name:
Nickname:
Email:
Security Image:
Enter the code shown:

I agree to the site's Terms and Conditions & Code of Conduct:

Most popular

  • Read
  • Discussed
  • Latest
  1. 1
    Court overturns rider's crash compensation
  2. 2
    Could Audi's e-bike become a Ducati?
  3. 3
    Stoner's GP Ducati fetches more than Rossi's
  4. 4
    Haslam, Melandri crash sequence
  5. 5
    A new Honda for £515
  1. 1
    Court overturns rider's crash compensation 24 comments
  2. 2
    New colour for Triumph Daytona 675 14 comments
  3. 3
    Caption That: War machine 22 comments
  4. 4
    Hickman kicked from Kawasaki BSB 8 comments
  5. 5
    Having a Randy Mamola moment 6 comments
  1. 1
    New: Suzuki's cool 2012 casual clothing
  2. 2
    Racing that Rossi can appreciate
  3. 3
    Crutchlow: best British start since 1988
  4. 4
    Fans against Manx GP changes
  5. 5
    Rossi: 'I just want a little more brawl'

Reviews

  • Read
  • Rated
  • Latest
  1. 1
    Yamaha YZF-R125 (2008 - present)
  2. 2
    Suzuki GSX-R1000 K5-K6 (Suzuki GSXR 1000)
  3. 3
    Suzuki DL650 V-Strom
  4. 4
    Suzuki DR-Z400SM DRZ400 (2005 - 2009)
  5. 5
    Kawasaki ZZR1400 (2012 - present)
  1. 1
    Triumph Tiger 800 XC (2011)
  2. 2
    Michelin Pilot Road 2
  3. 3
    Dunlop Roadsmart
  4. 4
    Michelin Pilot Road 3
  5. 5
    Kawasaki GPz900 R
  1. 1
    Bridgestone Battlax BT-090 Pro
  2. 2
    Dunlop Sportmax GPR Alpha 10
  3. 3
    Michelin T63
  4. 4
    Michelin Pilot Activ
  5. 5
    Michelin Power Pure

Latest Discussion

ONE armed MX rider! amazing!
by ToofastMax
1 reply
Talkback: Rossi: 'I just want a little more brawl'
Is this Rossi's way of saying that he's so bored fighting the Duke and the resultant midfield finishes that he's going to start some serious...
by Leon Trotsky
1 reply
Talkback: Racing that Rossi can appreciate
BBC shold employ this commentator. Be more lively than the drab of parrish and cox
by Drapes
1 reply
valve clearance keeps getting biger
by skikman
3 replies
Talkback: Buyer Guide: Honda Hornet 600
been loving my 98 for about 3 years now... practical fun motor - done minor mods I went along - braided lines, ohlins suspension - forks ...
by marinHK
1 reply
Facebook

Become a fan of Visordown

Twitter

Follow us on twitter

Subscribe to Bugsplat Newsletter

Click here

Parenting

  • Junior
  • Practical Parenting
  • ThinkBaby
  • MadeForMums

Other Immediate Media Sites

  • RadioTimes
  • Gardeners' World
  • GOLFmagic
  • OUTDOORSmagic
  • Visordown

Our eCommerce Platform

About Visordown

  • Join Visordown
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & conditions
  • Support
  • Advertise with us

Your Visordown

  • RSS

Reviews

  • Custom reviews
  • Sportsbikes reviews
  • Tourers reviews
  • Classics reviews
  • Supermoto reviews
  • Naked reviews
  • Off Road reviews
  • Sports Tourers reviews
  • Scooters reviews
  • Adventure reviews

Insurance

Directory

Competitions

Features

  • Bikes
  • Columns
  • Riding Tips
  • Workshop
  • Reader Articles
  • Off the Wall
  • Video Wall

News

  • Racing news
  • Product news

Home

  • Trackday calendar
  • Gallery
  • Your Crash Gallery
  • 10 Sexiest Bikes
  • Bridgestone Bikers Club

Forums

  • Main forums
  • Supermoto forums
  • Racing forums
  • Bike Shop forums
  • Miscellaneous forums
  • Site issues forums
  • Classifieds forums
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms + conditions
  • Advertise with us

© Immediate Media Company Ltd 2012. This website is owned and published by Immediate Media Company Limited. www.immediatemedia.co.uk